When it comes to financial markets and stock investing, certain months tend to stir up anxiety among investors. Two months in particular—September and October—often carry a reputation for volatility, poor returns, and unpredictability. This belief has sparked considerable discussion among market analysts and retail investors alike. But are September and October truly bad months for financial markets and stocks, or is it more myth than fact? Let’s explore the historical data, common theories, and potential explanations.
Historical Performance: A Look at the Numbers
Historically, September has earned the title of the worst-performing month for stocks. According to data from the S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average, September has frequently seen negative returns over the years. Since 1950, the average return for the S&P 500 during September is approximately -0.5%, making it the only month that has consistently posted a loss over such a long period.
In contrast, October is somewhat of a mixed bag. While it is notorious for some of the biggest crashes in market history—like the 1929 crash and Black Monday in 1987—October doesn’t necessarily suffer from long-term negative returns. The S&P 500, for example, tends to recover later in the month, even if early weeks show sharp volatility. The month has actually posted modest gains on average, making its reputation more tied to isolated events than consistent underperformance.
September: The Problem Month
1. Seasonal Trends:
The tendency for September to be a down month may be influenced by seasonal patterns. Investors often refer to this as the “September Effect,” though it lacks a single definitive explanation. A possible reason is the slowdown in trading volume during the summer months as many investors and traders take vacations. After a period of lower activity in July and August, September often brings rebalancing and profit-taking, causing stock prices to dip.
2. Tax-Loss Harvesting:
September is also a time when investors, particularly institutions, start reviewing portfolios and adjusting for tax purposes. Investors may begin to sell off underperforming assets to realize tax losses, which can drag down stock prices further. This contributes to negative sentiment and increases downward pressure on the markets.
3. Economic Data and Corporate Earnings:
September coincides with the end of Q3, prompting investors to focus on corporate earnings reports that are released in early October. Any signs of weakness in these reports, along with slowing economic indicators, can fuel investor uncertainty, leading to selling pressure.
October: Volatility but Recovery
October’s reputation as a volatile month has its roots in several historic market events. Major stock market crashes, such as the Panic of 1907, the Crash of 1929, and the infamous Black Monday in 1987, all occurred in October. However, this doesn’t tell the full story.
1. Post-Summer Recovery:
While early October may witness volatile swings and even declines, the later part of the month typically sees a market recovery. This is sometimes referred to as the “October Rebound”. After September’s losses, some investors view October as a buying opportunity, particularly as year-end strategies start coming into play. In fact, many bull markets have started their upward trajectory in October, making it less dangerous than commonly believed.
2. Earnings Season:
October often marks the beginning of the Q3 earnings season, and strong earnings reports can help restore confidence. Companies with robust results can lead market rallies, helping to reverse negative trends from earlier in the month. This helps explain why October often finishes on a positive note despite early volatility.
3. Psychological Factors:
October’s reputation for being a bad month may also be rooted in investor psychology. Having witnessed crashes in previous Octobers, investors may be more skittish, leading to increased selling activity. This fear-based selling can exacerbate volatility, even when the fundamentals of the market are sound.
Market Crashes: Outliers, Not Trends
The idea that September and October are bad for the stock market is likely influenced by the outlier events that have occurred during these months. Market crashes and corrections, while significant, do not necessarily indicate long-term trends. When looking at historical data across decades, October is far from the worst month on average for stock returns.
In fact, August and November often see poor performance as well, but they don’t carry the same negative connotation. October stands out largely because of extreme events, not because it is consistently bad.
Should Investors Worry About These Months?
For long-term investors, the emphasis on seasonal trends or individual months should not overly influence their strategy. The stock market is inherently volatile, and while patterns do emerge, trying to time the market based on these monthly fluctuations can be risky. Most financial experts recommend that long-term investors stay focused on the fundamentals—corporate earnings, economic conditions, and their individual financial goals—rather than letting historical monthly performance dictate investment decisions.
However, short-term traders and those using more active strategies may find it helpful to be cautious during these months. Increased volatility can present both risks and opportunities, especially for those trading in options or derivatives.
Conclusion
While September and October have reputations as difficult months for financial markets and stocks, the reality is more nuanced. September does tend to post negative returns on average, but October’s bad reputation is largely due to a few isolated market crashes rather than consistent poor performance. Investors, especially those focused on long-term growth, are better off sticking to their strategy instead of making decisions based solely on these seasonal trends. Timing the market based on historical month-to-month performance is challenging and often not worth the risk. Instead, focusing on solid investments and maintaining a diversified portfolio can help investors weather the inevitable market fluctuations, regardless of the time of year.
You can book a free consultation with one of our Financial Advisers to learn more about our investment approach and how we can help you.
Disclaimer
This article is for information only. Please do not act based on anything you might read in this article. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of current or future returns. This article contains general information only and does not consider individual objectives, taxation position or financial needs. Nor does this constitute a recommendation of the suitability of any investment strategy for a particular investor. It is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any security or instrument or to participate in any trading strategy to any person in any jurisdiction in which such an offer or solicitation is not authorised or to any person to whom it would be unlawful to market such an offer or solicitation.